Should a concealer be lighter than your foundation? “Always go a shade lighter than your foundation.” The lighter tone will cancel out dark discoloration, but be careful not to go too fair. Concealers that are more than one shade lighter than your skin tone can leave you with a ghostly shadow.
Should concealer be the same shade as foundation? If you want to brighten up the under-eye area, select a concealer that’s one shade lighter than your foundation. For covering blemishes, match your concealer to your foundation.
How do I know if my concealer is too light? However, sometimes the concealer can make the skin look grey and ashy. The main reason why this happens is that your concealer is too light for your skin tone. Using a concealer that is two or three shades lighter than your skin tone might cause your under-eye area to look more grey.
Should your concealer be lighter than your skin tone? While under-eye concealer should be lighter than your natural skin tone (or red-orange if you’re colour-correcting), you want your all-over concealer to match your skin colour as closely as possible.